I have observed many otherwise sincere and dedicated practitioners of Qigong
embrace internal alchemy as an entree into some kind of elevated spiritual real estate; a
mentally created location characterized by the qualities of voidness, emptiness or the imaged
goal of immortality that becomes the desired pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.
One result of this is that after many months or years of dedicated practice, many
students and teachers become identified with a self-image of attainment. The mental
structure of the ego assumes an identity, albeit in this instance a spiritual identity, that
superficially replaces the ordinary, more pedestrian, material ego or self. This is a particular
danger in any teaching, but especially in those practices that emphasize the manipulation of
Qi or Prana in the form of ascending or descending channels or meridians such as
Conception and Governing vessels and the Thrusting Channel (Chıung Mo), or focus on
energizing specific centers or Chakras in the body as in some of the classic and modern
interpretations of the Indian Yogic systems. Perhaps even more disturbing is the common
phenomena of energy imbalances that often arise in practitioners of these forms. The level
and quality of energy suddenly awakened in these practices is not easily integrated into the
studentıs body/mind in daily life and may result in mental, emotional or physical
disturbances. This has sometimes been described as the Kundalini syndrome within the
tradition of Yoga or "Running Fire" by Oriental medicine.
To be fair, it should also be pointed out that there are some teachers of the Taoist arts
who warn that the mental manipulation of internal energies, channels, etc. is a dead-end.
Their emphasis, beyond embodying desired attributes of virtue and morality, is to simply rest
awareness in the body, initially in the lower Dantian, and allow the process of cultivation to
proceed naturally and effortlessly. In their understanding, not only is this approach more
consistent with principles of Wu Wei, it is also safer both physically and spiritually.
Wu Chi (emptiness) & Wu Wei (effortlessness)
The central paradox of Taoism - summarized succinctly in the first verse of Tao Te
Ching, begins with the warning:
"The Way that can be spoken of is not the constant way."5
It is no accident that one of the central sources of Taoist wisdom should state this
proviso at the outset. Fundamentally, what the Tao Te Ching tells us is that the Tao cannot
be explained or fully described by the intellect. The unrefined intellectual or discursive
mind, i.e. the categorizing mind based on past memory and future expectation, cannot by its
very nature ³grasp² the essentially ungraspable Tao. From the perspective of the Tao Te
Ching, the mind and language itself, i.e., mental and linguistic forms, even refined forms of
spiritual ideas and ideals, can only point to that which is beyond the mind. They can never
fully describe this realm of being since it is the very source or basis from which the mind and
all other forms of life derive. In this sense, mind, language, the very basis of thought, can
only describe itself and other forms, including the subtle forms of energy.
Another way of understanding this particular spiritual conundrum is within classical
Taoist ontology. This philosophical framework describes Wu Chi, the nameless, formless
Void and source of the Tao, as the source of the dual forms of Yin and Yang in all of their
countless permutations. This play of opposites in turn gives rise to the Five Elements or Five
Energetic Phases, and these, in turn, lead to the forms of life in all of its infinite
manifestations. And yet, at the end of the day, so to speak, all phenomena naturally and
easily return to the source, the un-manifested Wu Chi. Return to Wu Chi is essentially the
model for all Taoist cultivation methods.
If we transpose this "warning"- the inherent limitations of the mind's capacity to
describe the Tao- to the conventional practice of Qigong or Neigong, we may rightfully ask
the question: how can techniques or forms that work with energies of Yin and Yang, lead to
the formless or the Tao? Or, to put it another way, how can the practice of progressively
refined technique, no matter how subtle and sophisticated, lead to that which is by its very
nature beyond any technique? Can any progressive practice of self-development, whether it
is Qigong, Neigong, including the complex formulas of Inner Alchemy, lead through time to
that which is essentially selfless, formless, timeless and eternal? On the surface this seems
- 3 -
|